Cloning

Research Guide

2007

Valencia West Campus Library Tutorial Series

                                                   

Subject Guides West Campus Library Home Page Tutorial Series

SCOPE:

When newspaper headlines informed the world on February 22, 1997, that a sheep (whimsically named Dolly, after country-western singer Dolly Parton) had been cloned from an udder cell of an adult ewe in Scotland, many people panicked. If a mammal had been cloned, they assumed, the cloning of humans could not be far behind.   Scenarios of what human cloning might mean, most of them nightmarish, almost immediately began to appear in opinion articles and television commentaries. Indeed, fears of human cloning were so strong that less than a week after the sheep cloning announcement, U.S. President Bill Clinton called for a ban on the use of federal funding for any research that might lead to human cloning, and bills intended to ban all human cloning research outright were quickly introduced in both the Senate and the House of Representatives.

Supporters maintain that cloning has many potential benefits. For instance, Elizabeth Pennisi explains in Science that the goal of the scientists who created Dolly is to produce herds of cloned animals with inserted genes that will cause their bodies to make human hormones, drugs, and other substances useful in medicine. Such procedures could lower the cost of compounds currently available only in very tiny amounts. Other supporters claim that it could bring new hope to infertile couples who desperately want a child and are unable to have one in any other way.  (Opposing Viewpoints 2000) 

BACKGROUND INFORMATION:

The following sources will allow you to become more familiar with your topic, will give you ideas for narrowing your topic, and will serve as a starting point for your further research.

SPEECH TABLE ITEMS
CQ Researcher Issues
    Organ Shortage 2003 p.153+
    Food Safety 2002 p.897+
    Embryo Research 1999 p.1065+
    The Cloning Controversy 1997 p. 409+

The Ethics of Human Cloning:  at issue series

Cloning:  contemporary issues companion

Cloning: at issue series

AUDIO/VISUAL ITEMS
The Ethics of Cloning
VIDEO QH442.2.E84 1997 

REFERENCE ITEMS
Encyclopedia of Social Issues
REF HN 57 .E59

Encyclopedia of Bioethics
REF HM 30 .E52

The Gale Encyclopedia of Science
REF Q 121 .G35

McGraw-Hill Encyclopedia of Science and Technology
REF Q 121 .M3  

SUGGESTED TOPICS:

This topic is one which can be studied from a number of aspects and points of view. Some of these might be:

  • What are the potential psychological impacts of being born as a genetic duplicate of one's parents?

  • Is is ethical to clone human embryos?
  • What are risks and benefits of cloning? Does one outweigh the other?
  • Should infertile couples be allowed to use cloning?
  • Should research on cloning be made illegal?
  • Should patenting of human and animal genetic information be allowed?
  • Should federal funding be used for research on human embryos?
  • Should there be federal policies regulating genetic engineering?
  • What are the social implications of cloning?
  • What are the medical concerns of cloning?
  • What are the ethical concerns of cloning?
  • Does the 1st Amendment guarantee a right to conduct scientific research into cloning?
  • Could genetic engineering lead to "utopian genetics" or a "genetic class system"?
  • Is the Human Genome Project dangerous?
  • Is gene splicing environmentally benign?
  • Is eugenics dangerous?
  • Would it be ethical for parents to take cells from a child who had died suddenly in an accident and clone a replacement?
  • Does society have the right to intrude on the reproductive decisions of couples and individuals by imposing restrictions on cloning?
  • Should cloning be used to create organs for people in need of transplants?
  • LINCC and Ebook SUBJECT HEADINGS:

    CLONING SAMPLE LINCC SEARCH

    Biotechnology
    Cloning
    Genetic engineering
    Human cloning
    Molecular cloning

    BROWSE THESE CALL NUMBERS:

    QH 442.2 B through QH 442.2 S

    RB 155 through RG 133.5

    SB 123

    FULL-TEXT DATABASES:

    From your home computer, login using your borrower id ( the 14 digit number on the back of your student ID) and your pin (EITHER the last 4 digits of your SSN for returning users OR the last 4 digits of your VID number for new students).

    Academic Search Premier
        An interdisciplinary database that provides access to approximately 4200 periodicals; over 3700 are in full-text.

    CQ Researcher Online
        In-depth reports on a current topic.

    Expanded Academic ASAP
        Offers
    abstracts, images, and full text for scholarly and general interest journals embracing all academic disciplines.

    FirstSearch
        A collection of approximately 50 databases, many of which contain full-text periodicals.

    Health and Wellness Resource Center
        Full-text articles and reference sources in the all health fields.

    Health Source: Nursing Academic Edition
       
    Over 600 scholarly full-text journals, including more than 450 peer-reviewed journals focusing on many medical disciplines.

    Issues and Controversies
        Full-text periodical articles provide overview information for controversial topics.

    LexisNexis Academic Universe
        Full-text documents from over 5600 news, business, legal, medical and reference publications.

    MEDLINE (via First Search)
        Offers full text and abstracts in all  areas of medicine, including dentistry and nursing.

    Opposing Viewpoints Resource Center
        Opinion, reference sources and full-text periodicals and books for thousands of controversial topics.

    The Orlando Sentinel
        Full-text of the newspaper from 1985 to the present.

    Newsbank
         Full-text coverage for 24 metropolitan newspapers.

    SIRS Knowledge Source
        Selected full-text popular periodical articles and government documents.

    Science Complete
        Offers full text and abstracts in science and related areas.  

    WEB SITES:

    Web Search Engines Comparison Chart

    State Cloning Laws

    Cloning: A Webliography

    What is Cloning?

    The Cloning Debate

    Human Cloning and Human Dignity

    Human Genome Project

    MedlinePlus: Cloning

    SAMPLE GOOGLE SEARCHES:

    intitle:"human cloning" site:org
    (title phrase search and domain search)
    "human cloning" site:gov
    (phrase and domain search)
    cloning laws "united states"
    (keyword with default AND search and phrase search)
    inurl:cloning
    (url search)

    EVALUATE YOUR SOURCES:

    Distinguishing Between Popular and Scholarly Sources
    Evaluating Data
    Evaluating Internet Sources
    Using Primary and Secondary Sources

    DOCUMENT YOUR SOURCES:

    APA Documentation of Print Sources
    APA Documentation of Electronic Sources
    APA Sample Paper

    MLA Documentation of Print Sources
    MLA Documentation of Reference Sources
    MLA Documentation of Electronic Sources

     

     

    Copyright (C) 2007
    Last
    revised: 14 November 2007
    Valencia Community College
    West Campus Library
    All rights reserved
    This Research Guide was prepared by:
    Catherine Katz

    Hit Counter